
On 5 November 2026, OLG Stuttgart [Oberlandesgericht Stuttgart] ruled in favor of Ritter Sport in its lawsuit against Mannheim-based Wacker GmbH. The dispute concerned the square packaging of the “Monnemer Quadrat Bio” oat bar. At first instance, LG Stuttgart [Landgericht Stuttgart] had found no trademark infringement. Our trademark law expert Philip Kohl had assessed the case for dpa [Deutsche Presse-Agentur] ahead of the ruling, taking a position consistent with the OLG Stuttgart’s subsequent decision. His assessment appeared in publications including Süddeutsche Zeitung, WirtschaftsWoche and ZEIT.
What Is the Dispute About?
Ritter Sport has held trademark protection for its square chocolate packaging since 1996. In November 2024, Wacker GmbH launched an oat bar in packaging that was also square. According to Wacker, the name and shape were inspired by the Mannheimer Quadrate [Mannheim’s grid of city blocks]. Press reports indicate that Wacker is no longer permitted to manufacture or distribute the bar in this packaging.
Three Key Points
Oat bars and chocolate are similar goods. Trademark law is fully harmonized across the EU. Under the case law of the General Court of the European Union, chocolate and cereal preparations such as granola bars are similar goods for trademark purposes. Commercial practice supports this view: both products are often displayed in the same areas of stores, such as at the checkout or on snack shelves, and both serve as quick snacks on the go.
Shape and name reinforce each other. Consumers often see the shape of packaging merely as a design feature, rather than an indication of who made the product. This is not the case with Ritter Sport, as demonstrated by the proven acquired distinctiveness that enabled its registration as a trademark in the first place. The name “Monnemer Quadrat Bio” also emphasizes the square shape, however, as does the slogan used. This supports the view that the shape is perceived as an indication of commercial origin.
Protection extends beyond identical copies. Whether there is a likelihood of confusion depends on how well known the trademark is, the similarity of the goods and the similarity of the packaging. Where a trademark is very well known and the goods are similar, even nonidentical packaging can be sufficient. The fact that Wacker’s packaging may not be a perfect square is therefore not decisive.
Are Hanuta or Knoppers Also Affected?
Philip Kohl considers this unlikely. The judgment applies only between Ritter Sport and Wacker. Hanuta and Knoppers differ in both product and packaging, have been on the market for decades and are highly recognizable in their own right. After such a long period of peaceful coexistence, claims would also face a defense of forfeiture through prolonged inaction.
What Enterprises Can Learn From the Case
• A packaging shape can be protected as a trademark even without a logo or lettering.
• Whether goods are similar depends on their purpose, characteristics and distribution channels.
• Product names and designs should be considered together. A name that emphasizes a shape can make that shape an indication of commercial origin.
According to press reports, Wacker GmbH intends to take the case to the BGH [Bundesgerichtshof]. However, the OLG Stuttgart did not grant leave to appeal on points of law. We are following further developments.
BRP RENAUD is not involved in the proceedings. This assessment is based on publicly available information and press coverage.